From the NYTimes Opinion Section:

"Dear President Xi:

Please accept my country’s gratitude and congratulations as you embark on your third term as general secretary of the Chinese Communist Party. Though it may not be obvious now, we believe your reign will one day be recognized as one of the great unexpected blessings in the history of the United States, as well as that of other free nations.

A few exceptions aside, this was not what was generally expected when you first became paramount leader 10 years ago.

Back then, many in the West had concluded that it was merely a matter of time before China was restored to its ancient place as the world’s dominant civilization and largest economy. China’s astonishing annual growth rates, frequently topping 10 percent, put our own meager economic progress in the shade. In one industry after another — telecommunications, banking, social media, real estate — Chinese companies were becoming industry leaders. Foreign nationals flocked to live, study and work in Shanghai, Hong Kong and Beijing; well-to-do American parents boasted of enrolling their children in Mandarin immersion classes.

At the policymaking level, there was widespread acceptance that a richer China would be vastly more influential abroad — and that the influence would be felt from Western Europe to South America to Central Asia to East Africa. Though we understood that this influence could at times be heavy-handed, there was little political will to curb it. China seemed to offer a unique model of capitalist dynamism and authoritarian efficacy. Decisions were made; things got done: What a contrast with the increasingly sclerotic free world.

Not that we thought that all was well with China. Your rise coincided with the dramatic downfall of your principal rival, Bo Xilai, amid rumors of a possible coup. Longer-term challenges — widespread corruption, an aging population, the role of the state in the economy — required prudent management. So did the international resentments and resistance that swiftly rising global powers invariably engender.

Still, you seemed up to the job. Your family’s bitter experience during the Cultural Revolution suggested that you understood the dangers of totalitarianism. Your determination to crack down on corruption seemed matched by your willingness to further liberalize your economy — demonstrated by your appointment of the competent technocrat Li Keqiang as your premier. And your stay with a family in Iowa in the 1980s raised hopes that you might harbor some fondness for America.

Those hopes haven’t just been disappointed. They’ve been crushed. If there’s now a single point of agreement between Donald Trump and Joe Biden — or Tom Cotton and Nancy Pelosi — it’s that you must be stopped.

How did you do it?

Your war on corruption has turned into a mass purge. Your repression in Xinjiang rivals the Soviet gulags. Your economic “reforms” amount to the return of typically inefficient state-owned enterprises as dominant players.

Your de facto policy of snooping, hacking and intellectual-property theft has made Chinese brands like Huawei radioactive in much of the West. In 2020 F.B.I. Director Christopher Wray noted in a speech, “We’ve now reached the point where the F.B.I. is opening a new China-related counterintelligence case every 10 hours.”

Your zero-Covid policy has, at times, transformed China’s great metropolises into vast and unlivable prison colonies. Your foreign policy bullying has mainly succeeded in encouraging Japan to rearm and Biden to pledge that America will fight for Taiwan.

All of this may make your China fearsome. None of it makes you strong. Dictatorships can usually exact obedience, but they struggle to inspire loyalty. The power to coerce, as the political scientist Joseph Nye famously observed, is not the same as the power to attract. It’s a truism that may soon come to haunt you — much as it now haunts Vladimir Putin as his once-fearsome military is decimated in Ukraine.

You could still change course. But it seems unlikely, and not just because old men rarely change. The more enemies you make, the more repression you need. Surrounding yourself with yes men, as you are now doing, may provide you with a sense of security. But it will cut you off from vital flows of truthful information, particularly when that information is unpleasant.

The Achilles’ heel of regimes like yours is that the lies they tell their people to maintain power ultimately become lies they tell themselves. Kicking foreign journalists out of China makes the problem worse, since you no longer have the benefit of an outside view of your compounding troubles.

None of this solves our problems here in the United States. In many ways, your truculence exacerbates them, not least in the increasing risk that we may someday come to blows. But in the long-run competition between the free and unfree worlds, you are unwittingly helping make the case for the free. To adapt a line from my colleague Tom Friedman, does anyone want to be your China for a day? I doubt it.

Which is why we want to say thanks. We know our Union is faulty; we know our leaders are flawed; we know that our society’s edges are frayed. To take one hard look at you is to prefer all this to your dismal alternative."

🤣🤣🤣

    • JucheBot1988
      link
      32 years ago

      Alternately, “how many dumb things can this cracker say in a minute”

  • @SpaceDogs
    link
    20
    edit-2
    2 years ago

    This is so embarrassing

    Who the fuck writes something like this, then edit it, proceed to post it, and still not feel like a fucking loser afterwards. It’s making me feel like shit and I didn’t make this! It’s giving Disney Channel Movie realness.

    This is him

    • @Beat_da_RichOP
      link
      17
      edit-2
      2 years ago

      It almost reads like satire lol. Like something a user here would write ironically.

      Probably the funniest shit I’ve read in a long time

    • @Eat_Yo_Vegetables69
      link
      142 years ago

      lol typical westoid, their own empire is crumbling through their own incompetence and they still smugly tell others how to run their nation

  • loathesome dongeater
    link
    19
    edit-2
    2 years ago

    Yeah this is a new type of liberal that I spotted last month too. It was a Twitter user called noahpinion. They think that Xi is somehow steering China towards a collapse. I was wondering what their thought process was since China is objectively doing alright. This article helps in figuring that out.

    Edit: this article is a bit over the top. Author is either the crying wojack with smug mask IRL or it’s a deliberate attempt to mislead their liberal readership.

  • @mauveOkra
    link
    182 years ago

    Your repression in Xinjiang rivals the Soviet gulags.

    lmao

    Even better:

    Your zero-Covid policy has, at times, transformed China’s great metropolises into vast and unlivable prison colonies.

    and, pray tell, where exactly is China’s “truculence” you speak of?

    I hate that all the NYT is considered the cream of the crop and all the uni educated libs around me imbibe this crap uncritically.

  • Muad'DibberA
    link
    172 years ago

    This is some damn good pasta, so many classics in here. Some of my favs:

    Your war on corruption has turned into a mass purge.

    If there’s now a single point of agreement between Donald Trump and Joe Biden — or Tom Cotton and Nancy Pelosi — it’s that you must be stopped.

    Your zero-Covid policy has, at times, transformed China’s great metropolises into vast and unlivable prison colonies.

    The Achilles’ heel of regimes like yours is that the lies they tell their people to maintain power ultimately become lies they tell themselves.

    None of this solves our problems here in the United States. In many ways, your truculence exacerbates them, not least in the increasing risk that we may someday come to blows. But in the long-run competition between the free and unfree worlds, you are unwittingly helping make the case for the free. To adapt a line from my colleague Tom Friedman, does anyone want to be your China for a day? I doubt it. Which is why we want to say thanks. We know our Union is faulty; we know our leaders are flawed; we know that our society’s edges are frayed. To take one hard look at you is to prefer all this to your dismal alternative."

    • DankZedong A
      link
      112 years ago

      Boss, I´ve finished the piece you told me to write. Want to check it out?

  • @GloriousDoubleK
    link
    16
    edit-2
    2 years ago

    Huawei is NOT radioactive. Someone such as myself, a working class dude, doesnt immediately know how to get such a phone or if they are even serviced by American phone monopolies.

    Someone such as myself doesnt hate Chinese products as a principle. I just dont have easy access to them.

    • QueerCommie
      link
      92 years ago

      I’m dropping my iPhone for a huawei first chance I get (assuming I get any)

      • @GloriousDoubleK
        link
        92 years ago

        I just think it’s weird to accuse someone of having a toxic product as if you or me is saying this when we have never experienced them.

    • @knfrmity
      link
      62 years ago

      The beef with Huawei was less about personal smart phones and more about US intelligence and Five Eyes more broadly maintaining their backdoors into telecom infrastructure. When the equipment isn’t made by a company you control (either officially, by shared class interests, or by coersion) you lose the backdoors built into it.

    • @DoghouseCharlie
      link
      12 years ago

      Why is Huawei always singled out specifically? Why not Xiaomi?

      • JucheBot1988
        link
        3
        edit-2
        2 years ago

        It’s a better phone than Apple (founded by the “godlike” Steve Jobs) can make, and the US is salty

      • @carpe_modo
        link
        12 years ago

        Xiaomi won’t sell phones in the US already, so there’s not much to target.

        • @DoghouseCharlie
          link
          12 years ago

          Oh, well I’m in the US and I got a Xiaomi A2. But I got it off eBay. 😎

            • @DoghouseCharlie
              link
              22 years ago

              I only had a Samsung J2 before so I don’t have much to compare it to, I’m not too into phones. But it works for me and the camera is better than I’ve ever used.

  • SovereignState
    link
    152 years ago

    Aw, are we shidding and pissing Mr. Stephens?

    Seriously, bourgeois and pseudo-intellectual fearmongering about China’s rise fuels me.

  • @PolandIsAStateOfMind
    link
    152 years ago

    Though it may not be obvious now, we believe your reign will one day be recognized as one of the great unexpected blessings in the history of the United States, as well as that of other free nations.

    This, at least, is true (except the term “reign”) - all free people in the future will recognize this time is the time of the blessing in the history of the US and the world - the beginning of an end of US and its history.

  • QueerCommie
    link
    142 years ago

    They had me with that first half, I didn’t think it was going to get that cringe.

    • @mauveOkra
      link
      122 years ago

      I mean it started out cringe, but good lord…

      • QueerCommie
        link
        112 years ago

        I mean he started “congratulating” XI, I guess I brushed off the backhanded comment about the us being free as opposed to China, he seemed to be talking about how well they’re doing, I sorta assumed he meant he had lower expectations of XI than what happened, then it took a turn for the cringiest.

  • @Eat_Yo_Vegetables69
    link
    14
    edit-2
    2 years ago

    To take one hard look at you is to prefer all this to your dismal alternative

    lol this bootlicker, look at the state of his beloved masters first

  • KiG V2
    link
    82 years ago

    I’m overdosing on the brain poisoning jfc…

    Thanks for copy and pasting so I didn’t have to click on that shit site, and thanks for sharing. It’s bizarre the depths people will go to, the strange monsters they will piece together in their mind, to stay in the neoliberal narrative. Gonna go put an ice pack on my head now lol

  • JucheBot1988
    link
    72 years ago

    Having ingested so much copium, I am now legally unfit to drive.