First of all, consider that most major media content from official sources like TV shows and movies are geolocked to approved countries. This has way more to do with copyright and licensing than censorship, but it’s what it is.

Second, consider the fact that every VPN around the world advertise that “if you’re in China, you can use us to get past censorship” in their marketing. Now, how many VPNs that Westerns use have an actual endpoint inside Mainland China? Totally legal to do btw, but how many prividers actually do it? Which, fun fact, the simple act of jumping the great firewall isn’t illegal. It’s only illegal of you commit a crime while bypassing the firewall, like if you were posting on a Western porn site or something, in which case it could be used to increase sentencing in court. Technically you can only use VPNs by Chinese companies (many of which still let you jump the firewall BTW), but as far as I know they don’t enforce it that much considering how prevalent Western VPNs are over there, and the fact they if they really cared they would have blocked all the major foreign VPN endpoints. Watching even explicitly state censored stuff isn’t illegal, it’s only illegal if you make, advertise, duplicate, or distribute it. Actually, additional fun fact, access and possession of porn is generally legal in China, they only criminalize, again, making, distributing, duplicating, or advertising it, that’s just their general philosophy when it comes to banned media.

Third, consider piracy. How often do you see Chinese media on western torrent sites or illegal streaming sites? I dunno about you, but pretty much never for me. Meanwhile, plenty of Chinese illegal streaming sites have all the Western shows you could want, and Chinese people torrent stuff all the time. Piracy is technically illegal in China, especially since torrenting counts as distribution, but I’ve personally never heard it enforced for regular Western movies and TV shows, only for porn and stuff like that. And there are tons of Chinese streaming sites, hosted in China, which you’d think would be pretty easy for them to shut down if they actually cared about it.

All in all, Chinese people aren’t starving for Western “freedom” media. The West is starving for Chinese media.

ButtigiegMineralMap
link
fedilink
13
edit-2
12d

In the Chicago Tribune, they mentioned that in the past, as awful as US book banning was, it was limited to specific titles and not ranges of titles. I.E: Ban Book A on March 1, Ban Book B on March 15, Book C on March 20, etc. nowadays, the new standard is to ban several books all of a similar topic at once. I.E: books called “GenderQueer”, “Nonbinary” or “Intersex” in titles are banned on same day. So those books can’t be in school libraries. The article mentions that the US is going into a record year of book bannings.

@rigor
link
fedilink
812d

Also: language barriers and travel. Barley any non-Chinese sleek Chinese, sure it’s a difficult language to learn, but Chinese kids all study English from very early in their education. In China you can easily find foreign media with Chinese subtitles. How much Chinese media (including social media) do westerners consume?

If a Chinese person wants, they know how to, and can see western media. Many foreign movies are popular in China. Inversely, westerners have no idea about Chinese media, let alone Chinese culture, society, history, politics, etc.

A westerner would struggle to name a Chinese politician besides Xi; yet there are many who are influential. You can’t understand any countries politics by only knowing of their leader. Chinese history is many thousands of years old, yet Chinese kids also study western history and art, among other things.

I visited one of the most famous western (historical) art museums with a Chinese person, from the mainland, and they recognized as many prices of art as a person from that country would. This was in Europe (most Americans study art much less in their education).

Chinese people learn western languages, see western media, can travel to the west, and can study in their universities. Westerners largely do none of this when it comes to China. Even so, Chinese is a wonderful language, and China has incredible media, attractions, universities, etc.

In essentially all respects, westerners think they have a more accurate view of China because of their “democracy” and “free press”. Yet they are in reality so ignorant about China, that they are blind to the reality: westerners live in a box with one way mirrors looking back at them, they see their own atrocities in the reflection and project their crimes into others, yet those others can see the west clearly.

@mlcolo
link
fedilink
512d

ironic that “free” people know less about the people in the “tiranny” than chinamen knowing about “free” people

@holdengreen
link
fedilink
5
edit-2
13d

It’s only illegal of you commit a crime while bypassing the firewall, like if you were posting on a Western porn site or something, in which case it could be used to increase sentencing in court.

Do people actually get sentenced in China for amateur porn? (not the stated context specifically I assume)

@Aria
link
fedilink
713d

Difficult to verify if it’s amateur or produced to look like amateur, or amateur with plans for growth. It’s illegal so I don’t think it’s unreasonable for them to enforce evenly across the board.

@UserServiceable
link
fedilink
7
edit-2
5d

deleted by creator

@lil_tank
link
fedilink
413d

Wait I don’t understand, I can go on Baidu without a VPN or anything, what do you mean by VPN having no endpoint in the mainland?

AgreeableLandscape☭
creator
link
fedilink
613d

It’s like Netflix. If you try to watch a show online and you’re not located in China, they just won’t let you.

@UserServiceable
link
fedilink
8
edit-2
5d

deleted by creator

@frippa@lemmy.ml
link
fedilink
4
edit-2
13d

I live in a w*stern country and I have a vpn that has an Hong Kong Relay, can I watch Chinese stuff?

@Munrock
link
fedilink
512d

It’s a completely different ecosystem.

Even Alipay, which is all over China, has to have a separate app for HK - AlipayHK. They’re not interchangable, with few exceptions such as travel payments. Different prices, different availability, different everything.

AgreeableLandscape☭
creator
link
fedilink
3
edit-2
13d

I think most Mainland stuff is still accessible from HK, but not all. Again, copyright and licensing are to blame.

@ybl
link
fedilink
212d

To be honest, I think it’s a simple case of what’s more in demand. A vast majority of non-Chinese speaking population does not want to or can not consume media in Chinese and because of that there are no easy off the counter solutions.

@UserServiceable
link
fedilink
14
edit-2
5d

deleted by creator

This is a Dengist community in favor of Bashar al-Assad with no information that can lead to the arrest of Hillary Clinton, our fellow liberal and queen. This community is not ironic. We are Marxists-Leninists.

Affiliated Discord!

Coming soon to Element as well

Rules:

No ableism, racism, misogyny, etc.

No being pro-Amerikkka

No being an electoralist or a lib (of course)

Moderator discretion

This community is explicitly pro-AES

No dogmatism/idealism (Permanent Revolution type stuff, anarchism, etc.)

  • 12 users online
  • 126 users / day
  • 188 users / week
  • 320 users / month
  • 1.19K users / 6 months
  • 2.45K subscribers
  • 6K Posts
  • 42.3K Comments
  • Modlog