Its also impractical and entirely opposite to the decades long Chinese naval strategy. China doesn’t have an effective blue water navy anywhere near the strength of the US’, and the PLAN would get sent to the ocean floor the second they attempted to break out towards the second island chain.

Almost because their naval strategy is focused around a green water navy centered on maintaining superiority of China’s coastline and everything within the first island chain. Leaving US naval assets unable to maintain supply lines to Taiwan and the Philippines, with any vessels they send getting swarmed my smaller craft and AShM’s.

This doesn’t contain any animal products. Why would it need the tw?

And who are you to speak for all Native people? Or are you saying they are a monolith who share your identical approach? Or are those other native people wrong and only you’re right?

Neither am I hostile to the idea they should be bettered. You can keep making any claim you’d like, that doesn’t make it true. So please, stop trying to shove words into my mouth.

Removed by mod

Which is who? Is communist praxis mass-genocide now? I must have missed those chapters in Capital and What is to Be Done.

You live in a fantasy world you’ve made in your own mind. You’re acting like I have any problem with indigenous people AT ALL, and not that my problem is you frothing at the mouth about how white people keep ruining any Marxist spaces and that it’s YOUR space because YOU want it to be.

I agree wholeheartedly with your point.

The only problem is that utterly massive portions of the black community, Latino community, Asian communities, and other races all participate in that “suburban settlerism”. Making race based division in this case pointless.

This is where Starbucks leftist came from. No clue who he is referring to with this. This is the classic conservative line.

But did you forget that Russian capitalist arms companies have to make profit?

I’ve tried to say this for years at this point, but I feel like people here have gone way to far in their “critical support” and genuinely believe they Russia is the second coming of the Soviet Union…: when they’re an opportunistic, rabidly reactionary, capitalist state. One that just so happens to be anti-US.

OP gave the game away. They legitimately just despise white people and saying that white people should not be part of the revolutionary movement is exactly what they meant with their statement.

Removed by mod

Wouldn’t quite literally every single person in the United States fit the first definition?

Unless you mean directly which means that the population percentage which fits that definition drops to a tiny tiny amount.

Again, you are conflating race and settlerism. The US is a white supremacist state, but you are using settler and race interchangeably.

Who is a settler?

Removed by mod

Then who is a settler in the United States at this point? For Israel the distinction is easy. The lines are to muddied in the US.

Yes it is a white supremacist system, but settlerism is entirely obsolete save for the vestiges of colonial policies that are still maintained.

I would suggest reading through their comments. They believe that no one beyond black individuals descended from slaves and indigenous population deserve to participate and lead revolutionary organizations and that white participants can neither understand nor have a place in a decolonial world.

They froth at the mouth about “Starbucks leftists” over and over. This person is not serious.

“Deep issues due to the settler base of the parties”

Ie: it’s not government interference or other issues, it’s the white people who ruin everything.

They did not leave because of sanctions, they reconsiders buying Syrian oil because of sanctions in 2018, four years after they pulled out. Your information is wrong again.

Why would they abandon their oil fields and pipelines?

The author doesn’t refute labour aristocracy? He simply states that even the labour aristocracy can be mobilized against the the bourgeoisie because they themselves are suffering under capitalism.

A McDonald’s worker is “labour aristocracy”, do you think they aren’t ripe for radicalization? The author is stating that pushing them away from the movement based on race is foolhardy and bizarre.

“No one said anything….”

Who is OP referring to then. Which group of people do we think op is talking about.