So, back when I was a social-democrat slightly intrigued by communism I tried to listen to “both sides” to form my opinion and so I looked for videos from both communists and anti-communists. Out of the few things I watched I retained mostly, “Debunking every anti-communist argument ever” by spooky scary socialist on the pro-communist side and this series of 3 videos on the anti-communist side:

Marx, responsable des goulags ? La lutte des classes

Critique de la lutte des classes selon Karl Marx

Critique de l’économie selon Karl Marx

Those 3 struck me as relatively convincing at the time (I knew nothing about Marxism whatsoever back then).

Recently, seeing recommended videos from this channel made me look back and wonder how I would see these same videos now as a Marxist-Leninist and after procrastinating it for months I finally decided to re-watch them. And low and behold, they are dumb.

The youtuber makes a big show of explaining his bare minimum knowledge and shaky comprehension of Marx’s writings which makes it looks like he know what he’s talking about to the uninitiated but it’s really mainly the old anti-communist drivel: denying class struggle and the labor theory of value, pretending that communists want a perfect utopia and say “that wasn’t real communism” when AES are brought up, pretending that Marx was an accelerationist, etc…

I would be interested in having other MLs opinions on this brainrot, especially since for better or for worst it has been part of my political evolution.

  • redtea
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    26
    ·
    3 days ago

    almost nothing was created …

    In the place where history saw the fastest ever rise in productivity until China improved on Soviet economics.

    Before the dissolution of the USSR, Ukraine was an industrial powerhouse. Then the capitalists sold it all off and now look at the place.

    The problem is that violence and ideology do not cancel out…

    What Marxist says they do?