As communists, we understand the causes of many of our woes in the modern life (i.e. class warfare, exploitation, etc), we are also not the most spiritual folks (at least from my anecdotal experience). Both things usually don’t mix well with this now trending topic of meditation and mindfulness in the West. Unfortunately, as with everything on capitalism, meditation was commodified, and often as not sold as the new snake-oil for mental health and improvement of lifestyle for the mordem working class of big cities, masking the causes of the many issues afflicting us in this late stage capitalism. HOWEVER, we know that meditative practices predate capitalism by several centuries. Also, anyone who’s been serious on the practice, knows that there is much more to meditation than what your mindfulness app endorsed by The Economist is promising you (helping fall asleep, focus, put up with your insufferable boss or wtv). So I’ll stop rambling and just go to my question: anyone has any Marxist oriented views on meditative practices? It’s something that interests me much, since the practice is totally self-oriented, and so, much less likely to be subject of socialism/communism discussions, but at the same time, in the East the practice is much more common and widespread, so in China, for example, there must be some interesting views on this.

  • Muad'DibberA
    link
    13
    edit-2
    2 years ago

    I consider myself a Buddhist (therevada school), but don’t try to reconcile the pacifism or idealism in it, which I completely disagree with.

    We also can’t forget that “mindfulness” has been used historically and currently in vile ways:

    • as a murder-focus tool: japanese imperial soldiers used it, and modern militaries are incorporating mindfulless routines.
    • for exploitation: US tech companies use it (and have mindfulness departments) to make their workers more productive in order to extract more profit.
    • as an opiate / pacification tool of the people: its marketed to workers as a way to “individually” solve mental ailments and stresses caused by external things. Even US cops are using it to “de-stress” from the tough life of fucking over poor ppl all day.

    There’s a wonderful and entertaining book called, McMindfulness that goes into this deeply, and serves as great a materialist critique of modern idealism in religion.

    There is one type of meditation which I think is helpful tho, because its unitive and collective-focused, called metta meditation, focused on extending compassion to increasingly larger groups of beings. I’m trying to read more books about it specifically because it seems to stand in contrast to the mindfulness movement, which is all about personal empowerment.

    • @coluna_prestesOP
      link
      62 years ago

      You hit the nail on the head with that book recommendation. That was exactly what I was looking for. Thank you so much, comrade!

      • Muad'DibberA
        link
        52 years ago

        No probs. The book is really funny too.