Hey all,

I’m currently developing a Marxist-Leninist analysis of settler colonialism, especially in light of the situation in Palestine, and am going to read Settlers: The Mythology of the White Proletariat by J. Sakai for the first time. Before I do I was just curious what other comrades think of the book and its analysis? It seems a pretty controversial text among many online Marxist groups, to whatever extent that matters, but as an Indigenous communist I feel having a clear and principled stance on the settler question is important for all serious communists. I’m not sure if I’ll agree with Sakai specifically, but since I generally agree with the opinions of y’all, I was curious as to your thoughts on the book.

  • WayneBarloweFan
    13·
    9 months ago

    In my opinion it’s mostly factually and emotionally accurate for the time

    With all due respect this means absolutely nothing and this is not the foundation for a serious conversation.

    You should probably look at what the book has wrought before you start talking about how great its vibes are. You familiar with a Mister Gazi Kodo?

    • QueerCommie
      6·
      9 months ago

      All I’m saying is it has some decent history and it’s pessimism made sense for the time. Writing a book and getting some dogmatic and uncritical followers is different from starting a cult. That’s like blaming mao’s writing for polpot and Gonzalo.

      • WayneBarloweFan
        11·
        9 months ago

        You would really enjoy Samir Amin’s perspective on Maoism vs Sovietism I think

        If I have any weird middle of the night rancor in my posts (it never feels like it at the time) just know I’m tired of hearing the same pseudoleftists like Sakai and Zizek get play over dependency theorists and other interesting shit like that

        • QueerCommie
          3·
          9 months ago

          Link it? Sakai is far better than Zizek. Sure he’s a little overrated here, but he’s worth reading as long as you’re critical and reading more recent stuff with better specific analysis too. I agree there are a lot of other authors like Amine that deserve more attention.

            • QueerCommie
              3·
              9 months ago

              Didn’t he write a lot of stuff? Surely you can give me a couple of suggestions or a place to start.

              • WayneBarloweFan
                3·
                9 months ago

                Galeano’s open veins

                Eurocentrism & russia and the long transition from capitalism to socialism are highly relevant bangers from samir amin. Also the future of maoism though a bit old

              • WayneBarloweFan
                2·
                9 months ago

                Yea I’ll help with that I’m just finishing up my parapolitics annotated bibliography which is another blindspot for many