I feel like the sex trade issue is one of the most divisive issues out there. I find people so candidly talking about it, from jokes about pimping people out being regular, to others admitting that they distribute pornogrophy on multiple platforms as a hobby. I dont remember people being routinely candid about this until the past year or so. I mean that could be prosecuted in some countries I think. Maybe im unlucky?
I feel like questioning when it comes up it is as divisive as conversations about China/Russia human rights, or religion. And I hear this from anyone, from my coworkers who are entreched in the gig economy to gender studies phd students in the ivory tower. There is no greater can of worms than saying maybe distributing porn is a net loss for humanity, or paying for porn doesn’t make things more ethical, yet it seems so painfully obvious to me that it would not even need to be said.
I get that this is mostly just the liberal take im seeing its just strange that there is such a lively consensus. People are so bold and just assume others believe the same as them. And the irony is unbearable, a fun time of dunking on libertarians routinely preceeds glorifying the sex trade. Do other people see this where they live or is it just me? I feel like my partner and I, and a few maoists I know are the only ones I know that are sex trade abolitionists.
Before my words are twisted: it’s worth noting that prohibition via imprisonment of those in the sex trade is a catastrophic and majorly anti-woman (not always women) and majorly anti-victim reaction. There’s a tendency to paint “SWERFs” as, well, “sex worker exclusionary radical feminists”, rather than what they typically are, feminists who support victims getting out of the sex trade. This is to be done by eliminating poverty, harsh sanctioning and punishing of Johns and pimps, and offering free and accessible vocational training to people currently in the sex trade, as well as a legally enshrined guarantee of non-punishment for being in the sex trade.
A common argument I hear from those in favor of prostitution is “well disabled, ugly and old people need and deserve sex, too!” How utterly ableist, ageist and borderline fetishistic to assume that these people couldn’t have sex or worthwhile relationships without paying for them. What needs to be done is the destruction of an ableist and individualist society and the creation of one that will allow these groups to prosper in their communities and create meaningful romantic and friendly connections with others. Not state-sanctioned prostitution rings. Also, hate to break it to anyone that thinks this, sex is not a basic human necessity or right. You’d think groups that pretend to understand consent and often claim that men have no inherent right to women’s bodies would actually understand this, but many of them seemingly don’t. The state should not exist to give you a girlfriend.
Excellent post. For those wanting to learn more, here are some resources on the sex trade.