No such thing as class reductionism

  • @lil_tank
    link
    1317 days ago

    It’s a wierd take, I’ve never seen class reductionism defined like that.

    They properly understood the battles for racial and gender equality as constitutive elements of struggle for the working class

    Yeah that’s right, but who is calling this class reductionism ? If anything it’s an intersectional analysis at its core, understanding the intersection between class and other conditions.

    I’ve always seen class reductionism defined as an attempt to diminish the importance of those struggle, while here the author implies that Marxism fully incorporating those struggle is the thing they call class reductionism?

    I think they are good faith and got gaslit by the strategy of dirty words that liberalism relied upon for decades. He must have came across a lib saying that any attempt to build solidarity of all struggles by using class analysis is “reductionism” in order to use the rightful bad connotation of the word to smear a deeply progressive and revolutionary concept.

  • Nakoichi [he/him]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    8
    edit-2
    17 days ago

    What does this have to do with anarchism?

    This just seems like needless bait.

    Class reductionism is certainly not a myth, you need look no further than the patsoc phenomenon or stupidpol.

    To elaborate, the primary contradiction in the imperial core is colonized vs settler, this upends the typical class reductionist position that the cis-het white male proletariat is equally oppressed as others.

    I will also say that ignoring intersectionality as this post seems to imply is reactionary.

    • 🏳️‍⚧️Edward (it/its)
      link
      817 days ago

      A small part of SDS did class reductionism

      However, because it was only a small part, class reductionism doesn’t actually exist.

      In similar lines of thought, PatSocism and Maoism don’t actually exist. The fact that some people are doing CR/PatSoc/Maoism doesn’t matter, I don’t think it exists.

      • @DamarcusArt
        link
        717 days ago

        Ooh! How about we try that with capitalism? Only a small group of people are capitalists, which means it doesn’t actually exist!

        …did it work?

    • @EastgermankittyOP
      link
      -217 days ago

      You made your peace with neoliberalism and it shows.

  • QueerCommie
    link
    617 days ago

    There are patsocs, trots, and economists that are practically “class reductionists,” but nonprincipled marxist. Liberals do like to claim we’re “focusing too much on one identity (class) over others” which is silly.

  • @Jabril
    link
    517 days ago

    Do you, OP, believe there is no such thing as class reductionism?