u/Alwaysdeadly - originally from r/GenZhou
In my experience IRL (imperial core) and online, “Maoists” are often well read and intelligent but are also somehow completely unhinged. I mean specifically that kind of Maoist who rejects MZT and uphold Gonzalo Thought, for example. You know the kind.

Does anyone have an analysis as to what makes people become this sort of leftist, or any experience helping them back to the real world, as it were? All the Maoists I’ve known would make great comrades if they weren’t constantly wrecking or trying to wreck things in a given area. It may be of use to try to pull some back from the brink.

  • @archive_botOPB
    link
    1282 years ago

    u/yw4lkwhenUcanride - originally from r/GenZhou
    Show them the current CPC’s take on Mao, which is that Mao, although earnest, might have gone a little too far in his restructuring of China.

    If they cant take the word of the people who were affected by his policy then maybe you arent talking with a principled socialist.

    The main thing to realize is that each revolution is different, and can be held in high regards. To call oneself a “Maoist” is just saying I am a Marxist Leninist who refuses to acknowledge my own community/nations needs in lieu of accepting Mao’s reforms as a blanket algorithm for revolution. Thats not materialist.

    • @archive_botOPB
      link
      462 years ago

      u/goodmax11 - originally from r/GenZhou
      Really excellent point. If people who agree with you on worldview (communists) and lived through the policies and results then they’ll have a better and more accurate analysis than a westerner living under capitalism a world away

  • @archive_botOPB
    link
    1142 years ago

    u/EngineIsStalin - originally from r/GenZhou
    You have been permanently banned from r/communism. You can still view and subscribe to r/communism, but you won’t be able to post or comment.

    If you have a question regarding your ban, you can contact the moderator team for r/communism by replying to this message.

    • @archive_botOPB
      link
      572 years ago

      u/lil_oozey_squirt - originally from r/GenZhou
      Can somebody explain to me who the fuck is running r/communism and r/communism101? Apparently I got banned for “not being a Marxist”.

      • @archive_botOPB
        link
        722 years ago

        u/Comrade_Corgo - originally from r/GenZhou
        Maoists started banning anyone not anti-China and anti-existing socialism.

        • @archive_botOPB
          link
          322 years ago

          u/redroedeer - originally from r/GenZhou
          WHAT THE FUCK?!?!

        • @archive_botOPB
          link
          262 years ago

          u/darkcalling - originally from r/GenZhou
          This person also I believe seized control of the original discord for this sub. Not that I care but why does shit like this ALWAYS happen in discord? It’s this or some other factionalist bullshit and favoritism that results in splits and drama. Yet another reason I’m glad I don’t use that.

        • @archive_botOPB
          link
          122 years ago

          u/FeaturedDa_man - originally from r/GenZhou
          Isn’t that the person who bragged about running over a jogger and fleeing, and the person who calls everybody ableist when they tell her she’s a psychopath and this behavior isn’t okay

          • @archive_botOPB
            link
            -62 years ago

            [deleted] - originally from r/GenZhou
            Calling someone a psychopath is calling some a myth since it doesn’t be defined in the DSM-5 it’s like equating evil to a mental illness

            • @archive_botOPB
              link
              102 years ago

              u/FeaturedDa_man - originally from r/GenZhou
              I think everybody understands psychopath to mean an egomaniacal person lacking empathy, which that person clearly is. The DSM isn’t the authoritative source on these terms, just on current American parlance within the field, but even if it was it does define these traits as a subset of ASPD

        • @archive_botOPB
          link
          72 years ago

          u/lil_oozey_squirt - originally from r/GenZhou
          That’s bananas.

        • @archive_botOPB
          link
          52 years ago

          u/Visible-Ad-5766 - originally from r/GenZhou
          Uhh looks like MK Ultra shit

        • @archive_botOPB
          link
          02 years ago

          [deleted] - originally from r/GenZhou
          Language is bad but they’re probably talking about exposure therapy in the mental health context which has its own problems but they’re probably not advocating for drilling peoples brains to see how they react

          • @archive_botOPB
            link
            72 years ago

            u/NEEDZMOAR_ - originally from r/GenZhou
            check out the rest of the pictures, theyre a sociopath and should be isolated

            • @archive_botOPB
              link
              62 years ago

              [deleted] - originally from r/GenZhou
              Ok yep that’s definitely not what she was talking about fucking hell that’s bad

            • @archive_botOPB
              link
              62 years ago

              [deleted] - originally from r/GenZhou
              Oh it was an album I didn’t even realise

      • @archive_botOPB
        link
        202 years ago

        u/Ucsbantimperialist - originally from r/GenZhou
        I wouldn’t doubt that it’s just been silently taken over by Reddit admins and the feds who turned it into a psyop

        • @archive_botOPB
          link
          122 years ago

          u/yw4lkwhenUcanride - originally from r/GenZhou
          Its really not that outlandish. Reddit is fed territory and there have been admissions to this. I was getting into r/morbid which is just tiananmen square propaganda before I was awakened.

          Completely reasonable that the most obvious forum that someone would find when searching for a leftist space would be co opted and controlled by feds and the otherwise shitty people who work with them

        • @archive_botOPB
          link
          82 years ago

          u/EngineIsStalin - originally from r/GenZhou
          Lmao this is my theory too

      • @archive_botOPB
        link
        152 years ago

        u/ottermaster - originally from r/GenZhou
        I got banned for telling someone not to join the us military😎 the question was “I’m in a bad spot and I see the military as my only out. Should I join?” I think I said something like,” there’s a lot of really bad right wingers in the military so be careful if you do join. You shouldn’t because of….” I guess they thought me warning him of possible threats was enough for a ban.

    • @archive_botOPB
      link
      342 years ago

      u/Alwaysdeadly - originally from r/GenZhou
      Thank goodness.

    • @archive_botOPB
      link
      22 years ago

      u/yw4lkwhenUcanride - originally from r/GenZhou
      lmfao.

  • @archive_botOPB
    link
    712 years ago

    u/aimixin - originally from r/GenZhou
    There are a lot of different kinds of Maoists. If you mean online Gonzaloites, well, I don’t really agree that most Maoists are “well-read”. If they understood historical materialism, they wouldn’t be Maoists. Most just have a vague idea that socialism is about abolition of private property, and capitalism is all about private property, therefore they conclude you need to make all private property illegal immediately or else you’re not a true Marxist.

    Gonzaloites aren’t just anti-China. They also claim Fidel a bourgeois opportunist and turned Cuba into a colony and now today Cuba is an imperialist country. They stan Pol Pot as well and think he was a true revolutionary. Unironically they will tell you the Cuban revolution is bad but Pol Pot was good.

    No one can come to such absurd conclusions and be “well read” unless they’re intentionally reading the most absurd texts they could possibly find and refusing to read anything from the perspective of the people in those actual countries.

    No Maoist reads texts from Cuban communists or Chinese communists post-Mao. They only read Gonzalo approved texts, if they read anything at all.

    They won’t ever change their mind unless you can convince them to read texts from Chinese and Cuban perspective. They never consider the conditions people actually lived under but just judge everything according to how well it fits some utopian ideology.

    Take Cuba for example. They constantly say it was a “colony” because they continued to produce a lot of sugar. Sugar is the staple of their economy, if they stopped producing a lot of sugar the economy would just collapse and people would starve. They had to continue producing sugar and use that to fund diversification of the economy, which they have always tried a lot to diversify the economy and have succeeded in diversifying it a good amount. But because they did not immediately abandon sugar, Maoists use this as a “gotcha” that they were a colony.

    As Marx said, “The conditions of this movement result from the premises now in existence.” If have a revolution in is a country centered around sugar production, your material infrastructure is going to be centered around sugar production. You cannot just immediately abolish this, this isn’t an ideological thing, it’s a material thing. You need to gradually change it over time. Maoists have this “gotcha” book they keep sharing around proving Fidel was evil that constantly as their evidence gives examples of Cuba producing a lot of sugar.

    It’s so absurd. Maoists refuse to apply a material analysis to anything, which is why they believe China, which had just came out of a feudal society in Mao’s time, could implement a fully developed socialist economy by fiat, and think the only reason it failed is because there were too many nonbelievers.

    I cannot take Gonzaloites seriously at all.

  • @archive_botOPB
    link
    442 years ago

    u/hayasabruhzee2 - originally from r/GenZhou
    Safely ignore all gonzaloids, they are larping morons worship a fucking terrorist cult.

  • @archive_botOPB
    link
    402 years ago

    u/FuckThePopeJoinTheRA - originally from r/GenZhou
    Tell them that the Panthers are the best example of maoism possible in the imperial core and that they should stop larping and go work in a soup kitchen

    • @archive_botOPB
      link
      582 years ago

      u/parentis_shotgun - originally from r/GenZhou
      The panthers came about before modern maoism was really a thing: their greatest influences were mzt, malcolm x, and the cuban revolution.

      • @archive_botOPB
        link
        362 years ago

        u/FuckThePopeJoinTheRA - originally from r/GenZhou
        I’m aware comrade, I was just making a joke to roast them, whilst also giving them solid advice

      • @archive_botOPB
        link
        92 years ago

        u/REEEEEvolution - originally from r/GenZhou
        And Juche. Don’t forget that.

  • @archive_botOPB
    link
    242 years ago

    u/SietchJacurutu - originally from r/GenZhou
    ‘Cuba and Vietnam are imperialist but we should support the Taliban.’ Is one I got recently from online teen Maoists.

  • @archive_botOPB
    link
    232 years ago

    u/bluemagachud - originally from r/GenZhou
    I think they’re just vain contrarians, like trots, they don’t want to win, they’re just capitulationists who want social capital to use opportunistically

  • @archive_botOPB
    link
    32 years ago

    u/samubai - originally from r/GenZhou
    Really though, what is to be done?