• bobman@unilem.org
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    1 year ago

    Do you mean this referendum of secession: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1991_Ukrainian_independence_referendum

    Looks like Ukrainians voted 92.3% in favor of independence from Russia.

    What are you referring to when you say ‘Then they were besieged by what is ostensibly their own government.’?

    as Ukraine is the worst economically performing country in the world since the fall of the USSR

    Starting to think you’re talking bullshit, here. Have you seen Haiti?

    I dunno man, looks like you’re kind of just crafting a narrative without any legitimate reason to support it.

    The fact you’re swinging in the complete opposite direction of Ukrainian propaganda kind of just makes you look like you’re falling for and perpetuating Russian propaganda.

    • knfrmity
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      1 year ago

      The information is out there if you care to look for it. You can also stick your head in the sand and blindly call reality “Russian propaganda.” Reality doesn’t care. I could say the same to you in terms of crafting a narrative. What’s the legitimate reason to support the fascist Kiev regime? Blackrock has a legitimate interest, maybe some oil and agriculture oligarchs.

      Anyway, if you’re interested this may be an interesting place to start reading some historical context.

      https://www.liberationnews.org/should-we-really-blame-nato-for-the-ukraine-war/

      By besieged I mean just that. Donbas was shelled for eight years by the Kiev regime’s armed forces. There has been a civil war in Ukraine for almost a decade, one that borders on genocide against people of Russian heritage. Western media at least admitted this was happening until early 2022, now it’s considered a Russian conspiracy theory. Thousands of children and civilians have been killed by western supported Ukrainian armed forces in Donbas, and we’re just supposed to not care and call it fake news? What about the internationally mediated and agreed upon Minsk ceasefire treaties which Kiev just ignored?

      In terms of referendums I was talking about the Crimea, Donetsk, and Luhansk ones. Here’s a report some years on about Crimean’s feelings on the situation.

      https://www.mintpressnews.com/return-russia-crimea-story-referendum-lives-since/262247/

      In terms of economic performance, Ukraine’s GDP has contracted since 1991, Haiti’s has grown. It’s an imperfect measurement of course, but at least a fair playing field. Same goes for population. You can cut out 2022 given the war if you like, but the trends don’t change significantly.

      • bobman@unilem.org
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        1 year ago

        Yeah, ‘just find it yourself’ is a real shitty response when pressed for sources.

        You can ‘find’ anything on the internet if you look hard enough. That doesn’t mean it’s accurate.

        It’s better to be on the same page about where we’re getting our information from. In this case, it looks like you shared some very biased sources. Now everyone know you’re getting your information from fringe news that has an agenda to push and isn’t influenced by journalistic integrity.

        Hideo Kojima was right. There’s so much misinformation and half-truths on the internet, that anyone can believe what they want and they will have no shortage of ‘sources’ agreeing with them.

        I’m not saying you’re right or wrong, just that you may be influenced by the same propaganda tactics you’re accusing others of.

        In terms of economic performance, Ukraine’s GDP has contracted since 1991, Haiti’s has grown.

        This little tidbit right here makes it seem like you’re arguing in bad faith, though. The economies of Ukraine and Haiti are nowhere near comparable. It looks like you’re just trying to twist your brain in knots to avoid saying anything good about Ukraine, which leads me to believe you have been heavily influenced by propaganda.

        • freagle
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          1 year ago

          it looks like you shared some very biased sources

          So you want unbiased sources like the NYT that knowingly printed lies from the US government to justify war in Iraq? How about the newspapers who knowingly lied about Tonkin? The ones that knowing lied about Cuba?

          Do you know how far back this goes? Did you know the Opium Wars launched against China by the British were sparked by newspapers printing lies about China? Do you know who owned those newspapers? The British opium dealers. One of those was the family of Forbes. They took their opium money and invested in US railroads, then they took that money and made a global financial empire and a newspaper.

          There are no unbiased sources. Everything you think is unbiased is actually North Atlantic propaganda.

        • knfrmity
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          1 year ago

          It looks like we have to start at a much more basic level. I’d suggest starting with the books Inventing Reality by Michael Parenti and Manufacturing Consent by Noam Chomsky.

          The fact that you reject the sources I provided outright without considering them on their merits and the primary sources they cite says all I need to know about having a conversation in good faith.

          Coincidentally supporters of the fascist Kiev regime also twist their brains into knots. If you pressed me I’m not sure I could say anything good about the modern Ukrainian state. It’s a neoliberal nightmare, making life significantly worse for its citizens and residents, it’s killing civilians in cold blood, it’s threatening terrorist actions against supposed allies, it’s using Nazi symbology and fascist political strategy, and it’s taking actions that could result in nuclear war. It’s doing all this so that a few billionaires can collect a few more millions or billions. How is this defensible?