Day 3 was my Historiography class, so the class with the same professor who taught my genocide class. Iāpm just repeating this so it adds context. Anyway, class began with a small quiz, I guess every class will start with these to both get attendance for class and also to test our reading comprehension to make sure we are doing the readings. It was quite literally two questions: what our name is and something that happened in the readings. This whole class was just related to what we had to read beforehand: a section from Stolen Focus: Why you Canāt Pay Attention and How to talk About Books you Havenāt Read. He assigned these so we are made aware of how to focus as we, as historians, need to do so to do our job well. On of the readings talked about focus and how people arenāt actually mentally equipped to handle āmultitaskingā and how when our brain turns its attention to another task it actually has to almost reorient itself for the new task. Even if itās brief. This attention issue was mainly centred on technology, it was quite interesting. The second reading was about how to know about books even i y havenāt read them before; since we cannot read every book that exists we need the ability to locate a book within a larger category to talk about it (an example used in the book was how the author has never read Ulysses but can talk about it because heās read the Odyssey). It was also about reading books selectively, instead of reading the whole text you can read the table of contents, the abstract, keywords, introduction, book reviews, etc. Funnily enough when my Professor was telling us about book reviews he brought up the reviews oof his own book and while most of them were positive I guess one of them was pretty bad because my Professor straight up called the reviewer and asshole. Anyway, we have to learn how to be a cultivated person.
Sorry if class was fairly uninteresting, in a few weeks Marxism will be discussed so thatāll make for a more engaging post. My discussion during office hours with this Professor might hold your attention. We mostly discussed the assignments for this class and personal issues (no life details of course). For this class here is a paper and a presentation. The paper can be on any topic, so a person or historical event are all good, the only thing is that it has to do with historiographical methods. I have to write about two books that cover the same topic but go about it in different ways, when he told me this my immediate thought was Timothy Snyder vs Grover Furr, I did not tell him this but I did ask if an academic taking down anotherās work would be okay for this assignment and he said yes but we will have discuss it in depth. I donāt know if my paper will be on Snyder vs Furr but it was a thought I had. Maybe using Domenico Losurdoās book on Stalin vs someone elseās? Those are the two ideas I have but they are not set in stone, this paper is the last assignment and is due in December. I just like to get ahead of the game.
Next I asked about the presentation because I was going to have a BIG problem with it. This presentation is supposed to be a group project, which means I have to work with others. I am not good at doing that. I am quite shy in real life and have major social anxiety. If anyone remembers from semester three I had to do a seminar which gave me horrible anxiety, same thing is happening here. How the group thing works is that he will post the books that we have to read (only the segments provided, not the entire text) and people will just pick which one they want to present about, being grouped with others who chose the same. When I expressed how unhappy I was with this group situation he did allow me to choose to do one on my own if I really want to, semi-special treatment but other students can receive the same if need be. He said I could choose a work and he would allow me, and only me, to present on it. One of the books is Howard Zinnās A Peopleās History of the United States and I told him I was interested in that one, he said that it was a Marxist perspective and I would probably do well, or something along those lines I canāt really remember. I told him āwhoās to sayā as I am very uncomfortable bing explicit in my enthusiasm for Marxism because god forbid I get a lecture or penalized. Iām trying not to make my professorās hate me but itās hard to keep a sweet disposition when I am always on alert. Last time I was slightly open and āexcitableā I got that terrible email and it really ruined my outlook on university, at least here in Canada. With that I actually did ask him if we were going to have issues as I was still on edge from the last time we had a class together, I really needed to know, and he said āI hope not,ā so really itās just a me thing. During our discussion he described me as reticent. I had never heard that word before but when I looked it up I fear it is incredibly accurate. I feel bad because when I talk to him (after the email incident) I am incredibly monotone and stiff (except for that one time I cried, embarrassing) which I donāt want to be like but its what happens. Even when I was doing breathing exercises before entering his office I still had my metaphorical hackles raised.
When I got home I just could not stop thinking about this presentation, and when I do my anxiety spikes and I even shed a few tears. This is so stupid. I think I will do it alone since professorās usually run solo, but group or not I am so fucking stressedā¦ I might have to talk to him some more about it, not to waive it from my grade but just to give me tips or something.
You conveyed my own feelings on the matter to a T. Being reticent is not a good thing, unless youāre in the Hamilton musical I guess. The thing is, I never used to be this way. Have I always been shy with crippling social anxiety? Absolutely, but after getting into the groove of conversation and feeling comfortable I would share my beliefs, now I donāt. Why? Because of that email and argument I had with my relative, both combined made me fear ever being open lest I be accused of being a Russian propagandist or possessed by the Devil (I am not joking, I was accused of being at the will of the Devil post argument). Itās literally as you said, I learned that no one around me old understand or even try to understand what I am saying. I find the āconveying oneās ideasā thing also very difficult, but I guess like with anything it takes practice.
(continued rant about school, feel free to skip)
I know some people will say that the email I was sent wasnāt that bad at all and I am over exaggerating/catastrophizing, but what that email meant to me was that I had to tread lightly at this school, I could not use someone as educated and reliable as Ivan Katchanovski and I canāt talk too much about the Donbas/the conflict as a whole or else I will be labeled a naive idiot falling for Russian disinformation (I hate putting Russian in front of everything because it feels xenophobic but thats what they actually say).
I felt like such an idiot when writing my Donbas paper because I was terrified to go too deeply into the conflict (like using on the ground footage, plus I had to avoid all Russian sources since they would be labeled as misinformation) so what I ended up submitting was a horrible piece that isnāt up to my usual standards, and I genuinely feel like this professor thinks little of me because of how bad I probably did. My papers in other classes have been pretty damn good, but this one was a dud. That email did more damage than he couldāve imagined, it has stuck with me for all these monthsā¦ One day I would like to rewrite that paper, but without that fear, and I know itāll be so much better especially with all the new evidence cropping up.
As you can see Ive been pretty hung up on this issue and itās affecting my day to day life, I couldnāt even get a good nights sleep last night due to my horrible anxiety over it. Iām glad I have this space to share my thoughts and to be shared to.
I have been thinking about what to say that could help but I am a bit of a loss owing to my own deficiencies.
probably bad advice
All I can suggest is that you try to find some peers since you are in college. From what I gather you are probably a commuter, and I have heard that being a commuter makes making friends a little bit difficult. But there are avenues like clubs, sports, and your classes that can help. It is tough because you say you have anxiety around this so make of this what you will. Having people to talk to and shoot shit with might help.
Obviously I donāt know to what extent you keep to yourself and how much of it is simmering inside you so pardon me for any overreach.
This is good advice, so donāt worry about that. I know joining a club would probably be the best as it would be easier to converse with people rather than getting to know my classmates. The anxiety does halt me from joining a club but I know Iāll have to bite the bullet eventually. I do have friends outside of school, so Iām not totally alone, but I am aware that school peers are important.