• 113 Posts
  • 124 Comments
Joined 4 years ago
cake
Cake day: November 10th, 2020

help-circle
















  • I figure that this community should be pretty broad and include all types of anarchism at the moment until there are enough community members to start creating more specific communities.

    Of course, fascists who just put “anarcho” in their name like “anarcho-capitalists” will be banned on site. :-)

    Anarcho-pacifism is fine.












  • This was one of my main takeaways after reading Lenin’s State and Revolution.

    There’s a lot of bloviating, and throwing around of terms like ‘petite-bourgeois philistines’. But not a lot of substance when it comes to the details of why exactly we need a transitional state, and the particulars of how the withering away will begin.

    He talks about the need for power to be in the hands of the armed workers - but it seems to be just talk. There’s also a lot naivety in the idea of having a minimal government who are paid a small sum - why do we need these people? And knowing what we know about the nature of capital won’t these people and positions become corrupted? It’s the state, and capital itself we’re trying to do away with - not a change to a more benevolent group of capitalists who somehow know what’s best for all of us.

    It does all come off as very fanciful, idealistic, and wrapped up in the myth that humans are inherently greedy and stupid and in need of a patriarchal figure to guide them.

    In comparison I find a lot of anarchist writing more visionary, but also more pragmatic and backed up by sound reasoning.








  • Thanks, I already watched most of that one. I think he should remove the propaganda at the start of the video and lose the over the top production because he makes a few good points.

    I wouldn’t exactly call it a “debunking” though. It’s not as if oppression of Uyghurs and other Muslim minorities is some made up thing.





  • However you feel about RMS, I think we can all agree that the FSF goofed up.

    Whether it was a defiant announcement that they won’t let freedom-hating SJWs cancel Stallman, or an announcement of accountability, apology, or steps to address his behaviour — they should have made some kind of statement instead of just letting Stallman himself announce that he was returning without much explanation.