I don’t know how it would have differed from Reddit in this regard, but it would be quite suitable for a forum website to give thorough reviews of books. Some people give reviews of books on Tiktok where they just say the main topic of the book and that it’s ‘good’… good in what way? And like what other commenters have mentioned, some love too for nonfiction. Maybe we could even have discussions for fanfiction?
What karma? Spez started it by being a liar 🤷♂️ so I say it is natural that people stop supporting him.