huf [he/him]

  • 17 Posts
  • 1.6K Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: November 11th, 2021

help-circle













  • standard spellings will always privilege one dialect over the others. usually the dialect of the ruling elite.

    the only way out of this is to not reform the spelling. letting it rot will eventually get you to something like english spelling, which is often so far from the pronunciation that it’s just equally bad for everyone. and STILL standard english spelling privileges the prestige dialects, just not as much as a more recent, more phonetic orthography.







  • the shire was ~1400 years old by the time of the books, so not that recently.

    but it was far from sauron’s borders, wasnt a great power, not even a kingdom. it was in the territory of what had been arnor, and he’d already smashed arnor a thousand years ago or more. sauron also didnt think much of the other factions of western middle earth, he basically thought that as long as he could defeat gondor and prevent the already failing elves from fucking around, he would win. there was no need for him to deal with random little settlements like the lossoth or the shire.

    plus, it had the name “shire”, which is as generic as you can possibly get (Sûza is the Westron word for “province, sphere of occupation, division of a realm”,[1] visible in Sûza-t, “The Shire”).