- cross-posted to:
- news@hexbear.net
- cross-posted to:
- news@hexbear.net
You must log in or # to comment.
This is a prime example why adventurism is bad. It seems they were an more or less isolated group with a weapons arsenal which got busted. In the court case State and Revolution was used as supporting evidence for their alleged intentions of overthrowing the Russian government. This legal precedent will make it considerably easier for anticommunist forces within the Russian state to increase crackdowns. Ultimately these people actively harmed all organized communists in Russia and have nothing to show for it, nor were they ever close to achieving anything which could justify risking such an outcome.
Thats really unfortunate. I didn’t know Russia used court precedent as part of their law practice. For whatever reason I thought that was a UK/US/Common Law thing.
It doesn’t. Mostly. It’s like this - court precedent can’t be a source of law in Russia, but Supreme Court’s interpretations of contentious stuff are effectively mandatory, because lower courts have to keep in mind they can end up being overruled if they make a ruling that goes against those interpretations. And the Supreme Court ends up dealing with contentious stuff when it’s brought before the Supreme Court. So the Supreme Court can kinda set precedents. But not the other courts. Not even kinda.
It is a social precedent though. Not sure what kind. I’m leaning towards bad as being anti-war right now isn’t a great way to earn support in Russia. So entangling the word “communist” with that isn’t great.
Revolutionary defeatism does not apply when fighting a war against imperialism.
deleted by creator
Pretty sure that is some ultraleft stuff posted to undermine marxist leninist critical support for russia.
deleted by creator
That doesn’t sound like the KPRF.
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
I have the full context of the arrests of the Ufa “marxists”. I will share it later on so people could understand why it happened.
From my perspective, it seemed as a messy case where saboteurs misled new marxists into committing adventurism.
Context in Ru https://zona.media/article/2025/12/16/communists
deleted by creator
Here it is! https://lemmygrad.ml/post/10193899
deleted by creator
Probably. However, this jailing is still bad news
That’s why it is important to contextualize the news and even more for countries under siege by the imperialist.
Otherwise, you might end up making the mistake of feeling sad for a fascist collaborator posing as a marxist or leftist.
deleted by creator
It looks to me like the western press is reporting this as bad news because it fits their “Putin = dictator” narrative. Every article I’m seeing goes something like “anti-Putin activist jailed, says charges against him are fabricated,” etc.
Solidarity
